THE WORKING MEN PROJECT

EARLY 2004 NEWS STORIES

Prostitute's HIV-Related Charge Dropped in Plea Bargain

Experts: HIV Studies Needed Along Arizona-Mexico Border

Monitoring Indicates Safe-Sex Relapse in Boston

HIV Prevention Programs Failing; New Infections on the Increase

HIV Prevention Groups Say Bush Administration Is Targeting Their Work

AIDS Doctors, Activists Discouraged by Bush Stance on AIDS Programs

Rise in Iranian Prostitution Blamed on Strict Sex Rules, Economy

Appeal from Mahila Samanwaya Committee

EUROPAP: Promoting the health and wellbeing of sex workers in Europe

Queen’s AIDS project gets $3 million from U.K.

Gay Sheep May Help Explain Biology of Homosexuals

AIDS Deepens in Zimbabwe

Scotland Breaks Ranks Over Payouts for Hepatitis C Patients


Prostitute's HIV-Related Charge Dropped in Plea Bargain
Los Angeles Times (13.09.02):John L. Mitchell

In a last-minute plea bargain, prosecutors dropped charges against a woman who is HIV-positive and accused of engaging in prostitution. Panchita Hall, 46, was facing a second trial under a 1988 law that requires prostitutes who are HIV-positive and who have been informed of their blood test results to be charged with a felony upon their second arrest. She has been convicted of prostitution six times since she learned in 1995 that she is HIV-positive. Hall was arrested by an undercover officer in April. The jury in her first trial deadlocked, and an impasse was declared.

Deputy District Attorney Lori-Ann Jones, who tried the initial case, said the decision not to seek a second trial was made because "there was no assurance that another jury was going to reach a guilty verdict." Conviction under the 1988 statute carries a three-year sentence, but Jones had planned to ask for an enhanced sentence of as much as nine years for Hall. On Thursday in Compton Superior Court, Hall was sentenced instead to four years in prison for violating probation on a 2001 prostitution conviction. Jones said that with time served, Hall probably would be free in a year.

The law was first invoked in Los Angeles County in 1990 against a male prostitute who was sentenced to two years in state prison. Tens of thousands of prostitutes have been tested for HIV in the county as a result of the law. Slightly more than 200 have been convicted on a felony charge since 1995, police said.

Back to top

Experts: HIV Studies Needed Along Arizona-Mexico Border
Associated Press (17.09.02)

Poverty-forced prostitution among Hispanic men along the Arizona-Mexico border should be studied to see if the practice is driving up HIV infection, experts said last week at a bi-national conference on HIV/AIDS. "When these men who are traveling from Latin American and other countries end up at the border without anything, they see little options but to prostitute themselves," said Juan Bazan, director of the Bi-National AIDS Advocacy Project. "They will do whatever they have to to live. They don't see another option," Bazan said. "Many feel all alone, and when they enter prostitution, they also enter a circle of drugs and alcohol."

Besides drinking and taking drugs, the dangers are compounded because these men are not telling their wives or girlfriends what they have done - putting their mates at high risk of HIV/AIDS, said Juan Ruiz, of California's Department of Health Services. The findings are part of a three-year study that Ruiz released at the conference in Tucson, Ariz. "I don't think we know enough about the prevalence of HIV/AIDS along the border," said Sally Stevens, a research professor with the University of Arizona Southwest Institute for Research on Women.

The CDC estimates that 850,000 to 950,000 US residents have HIV, and one-quarter of them are unaware of their infection. In Mexico since 1983, there have been 52,000 reported AIDS cases, and of the patients afflicted, 20,000 are alive, said Carlos Magis, of the National Center for the Prevention and Control of AIDS in Mexico. In southern Arizona, El Rio Community Health Center is treating 1,350 clients for HIV/AIDS and expects a 15 percent increase in new patients by December, said Jane Chittick, CEO of the El Rio Foundation, the fundraising arm for the health center. "We are seeing five new patients each week at the health center for HIV/AIDS, and two of the five are women," Chittick said

Back to top

Monitoring Indicates Safe-Sex Relapse in Boston
AIDS Alert (01.09.02)

The trend of men who have sex with men (MSM) resorting to increasingly unsafe sexual practices is becoming apparent throughout the developed world, as studies continue to highlight increases in the prevalence of STDs. Studies presented at the 14th International AIDS Conference in Barcelona showed increasing STDs among MSM in New England's largest MSM clinical care site and at Paris STD clinics.

Fenway Community Health in Boston has charted STD trends among gay men and lesbians in New England for three decades. The clinic's records showed that the lowest prevalence rate in STDs occurred in the late 1980s and early 1990s, after AIDS deaths had become a strong motivating factor in safe sex practices. Gonorrhea cases had reached a nadir of 43 and there were no syphilis cases at Fenway in 1994. "Now that rate has started going back up," said Kenneth H. Mayer, MD, medical research director at Fenway.

"The number of STDs tripled between 1994 and 2000," Mayer said. By 2000, there were 113 patients diagnosed with gonorrhea and 10 with syphilis. Of these patients, 75 percent presented with no symptoms, and 10 percent had been notified by sexual partners. Earlier studies have highlighted similar trends in San Francisco, which also has some data showing increases in HIV infection rates among MSM.

The trend, however, is not limited to the United States. Paris experienced a sharp increase in syphilis cases between 1998 and 2001, according to another study presented in Barcelona. In 1998, there were four syphilis cases reported in Paris STD clinics; in 2001, there were 91 cases reported. Prior to the late 1990s, syphilis had been a rare disease in Paris, and its resurgence is consistent with evidence that gonorrhea cases also are increasing, especially among MSM.

"Therapeutic optimism is part of the equation," Mayer said. While MSM in their 40s and 50s have lived through a time when their friends became sick and many died from AIDS, the younger MSM have grown up with AIDS as a fact of life and have not necessarily personally been affected by it, Mayer said. Although data collected on HIV infection at Fenway are not precise enough to measure HIV prevalence rates over time, there is an increased likelihood that HIV rates have gone up in New England among MSM, just as they have in San Francisco, Mayer added.    

Back to top

HIV Prevention Programs Failing; New Infections on the Increase
Canadian Press (04.09.02):Dene Moore

In 2001, British Columbia had a modest but alarming increase in new HIV infections among both the gay and heterosexual populations - the first increase in six years - AIDS activists said Wednesday. The rate of HIV infection in the province declined annually to 413 new infections in 2000 from 840 in 1994. But in 2001 that number increased to 440. A recent Health Canada report found a similar increase among Toronto's gay population last year. Montreal was the only city studied that did not see the same rise in new infections, although researchers are unsure if that means the city has really bucked the trend that is also seen in the United States, Australia and the Netherlands.

"Despite 20 years of working to stop the spread of HIV, we find that those efforts are falling considerably short," said Glen Hillson, chairperson of the BC Persons with AIDS Society. New drug treatments mean more people with AIDS are living longer. That means more of the AIDS funding in Canada goes to caring for those who are infected and less goes to prevention programs, said Hillson. In smaller communities, HIV/AIDS still carries a stigma. "Homophobia prevents prevention posters from being put in public places," said Rich Marchand, a researcher with the Community Based Research Center. Needle exchange programs are the biggest investment in prevention in British Columbia, Marchand said. 

Women account for 25 percent of new HIV infections in 2000, Health Canada statistics show. "Yet in the heterosexual community, it's not even on the map," said Marchand. There are an estimated 15,000 Canadians infected with HIV who do not know it, according to Health Canada. Stephen James, a researcher for the group, said men who have sex with men account for 77.9 percent of cumulative AIDS cases among adult men in Canada and 71.3 percent of HIV-positive reports since testing began in 1985. "Although gay men continue to have the highest number of new infections, few prevention programs exist for gay men," Marchand said.

Back to top

HIV Prevention Groups Say Bush Administration Is Targeting Their Work
Associated Press (01.10.02):Laura Meckler

The Bush administration has pulled information about the effectiveness of condoms from a government Web site and is engaged in a "witch hunt" against those who promote condoms to fight AIDS, several groups charge. They argue that the administration is hostile to HIV prevention and sex education that is not based on abstinence-only, which discourages all sex before marriage and bars discussion of the benefits of birth control and condom use.

The advocacy groups said Monday they are particularly concerned about federal agency audits, now underway, to examine the finances and programming of AIDS groups. "It's a campaign to censor science and research, and it's a campaign to use government auditors to intimidate opponents of the administration on key policy issues," said James Wagoner, president of Advocates for Youth, a group that promotes education about birth control and condom use. The administration says it is simply making sure that tax dollars are properly spent. Health and Human Services Deputy Secretary Claude Allen called any suggestion of a witch hunt laughable.

Advocates point to a series of actions in the last year:*Information explaining the effectiveness of condoms in preventing HIV transmission has been pulled from the CDC Web site. Also gone is a section called "Programs that Work," which focused on HIV and highlighted several proven programs that involve condom use.

*A broad review of HHS AIDS spending, ordered by Secretary Tommy Thompson, is underway and includes grants to outside groups. Allen said he knew of no other HHS-funded programs undergoing similar scrutiny.
*The HHS inspector general is investigating at least eight AIDS programs to see if their content is too sexually explicit or promotes sexual activity.
*Members of Congress also have twice asked HHS to further investigate AIDS groups.
    

"There is a fear out in the community that if they produce something or say something inappropriate, or what is deemed as inappropriate, they will lose their funding," said Mary Ann Green of Florida AIDS Action.
    

Back to top


AIDS Doctors, Activists Discouraged by Bush Stance on AIDS Programs
Orange County Register (20.09.02):Mayrav Saar

On Thursday at the US Conference on AIDS in Anaheim, Calif., White House Office of National AIDS Policy Director Dr. Joseph O'Neill was booed and jeered as he spoke of President Bush's stance on AIDS prevention programs. The national gathering of doctors, social workers, patients and advocates seemed discouraged to hear O'Neill discuss Bush's policies in support of abstinence education and against federal funding for needle exchange programs.

"I know there are concerns in this room about the administration's policies, or what our policies are imagined to be," said O'Neill, who began treating AIDS patients as a San Francisco internist in 1982. "We have to try to bring more voices to the table. Abstinence is one of those voices," he said. "We have not made a dent in the annual number of new infections in years. And we cannot afford to close our ears to any ideas."

Local AIDS health care workers criticized Bush's policies as shortsighted and potentially dangerous. O'Neill said Bush's stance does not exclude safe sex education. But Dan Gleason, executive director of the AIDS Services Foundation, Orange County, said programs heavy in abstinence education have failed to ensure that young people use protection when they do become sexually active. "It's not an enlightened perspective," Gleason said. "It's a perspective that doesn't take good solid health education into account."

AIDS health care providers are also concerned that the administration is not committed to increasing funding for prevention programs. Prevention efforts in Orange County have been particularly difficult in Latino and African-American communities, Gleason said.

O'Neill received the biggest jeers when he discussed the administration's lack of support for federal dollars for needle exchange programs. "When they talk about not wanting to fund needle exchange programs, the government is not really thinking about future generations," said Neil Willenson, founder and CEO of Camp Heartland, a national summer camp program for children affected by HIV/AIDS.

Back to top


Rise in Iranian Prostitution Blamed on Strict Sex Rules, Economy
Associated Press (15.09.02):Ali Akbar Dareini

A recent serial killer in Iran was understood by some to be battling corruption and a social scourge - prostitution. Saeed Hanaei went to the gallows for murdering prostitutes. "If I removed corruption, it was for the good of the people," his gravestone read. Hanged for killing 16 women, many view him as a hero.

Official statistics in Iran suggest prostitution is increasing in the Islamic Republic. "Based on our findings, the number of prostitutes is unfortunately on the rise. There are now an estimated 30,000 working prostitutes in Iran," said Hadi Motamedi, a top official at the State Welfare Organization.

Motamedi could not say how much prostitution has increased, but women waiting on customers in the streets are more numerous than in past years. Prostitutes are believed to work independently, though police have reported organized rings mostly by women in private homes.

Iran's strict Islamic rules allow little socializing between the sexes, and young Iranians have been jailed and flogged for dancing together at birthday parties. "Parents who are suspicious of their children, don't give their children any choice or freedom, and always impose their thinking on them, force such children to flee homes," said Hamzeh Ganji. Ganji said young girls who leave home often must become prostitutes to survive.

More than half of Iran's 70 million people are below age 25. The unemployment rate is officially 15 percent, but private experts say it really is about 30 percent. One psychiatrist, Mahdis Kamkar thinks that the rise in prostitution is a symptom of broader social problems such as "troubled families, divorce, identity crises and social contradictions."

Ganji argues that allowing brothels to be legalized and run by Islamic rules would enable the authorities to control AIDS and other STDs, "and the rest of the society will live in peace without women afraid of being molested or wrongly approached by customers in the streets." But many clerics scoff at the idea that Islam could ever condone sex outside marriage.

Meanwhile, his family and others defend Hanaei, the serial killer. "I'm not sad that my dad is dead. I'm sad because he failed to achieve his goal," his 16-year-old son, Ali, told the Associated Press. Not everyone is happy with that response, including the government.

Back to top

Appeal from Mahila Samanwaya Committee


The time: 11 p.m., 29 August 2002. The place: Tollygunj, a red-light area in Kolkata. The incident: Local mastans (anti-socials), who masquerade as the neighbourhood big brothers, severely beat up Rekha Lodh, a sex worker. They said she needed to be punished for having had a public altercation with her current husband. In the middle of the night Rekha and her two young children are thrown out of her room and locked out. The reason – she needed to be taught a
further lesson, the beating alone was not enough.

 

Shapna Gayen, also a local sex worker, and the President of Durbar Mahila Samanwaya Committee, a sex workers’ collective, vehemently protests. With hersupport Rekha dares to lodge a complaint with the police. DMSC too lodges a first incident report. The police take no action against the perpetrators.

 

The bigwigs of the neighbourhood, who live off the earnings of sex workers through extortion and running various other rackets in the locality retaliates by launching a hate campaign against Shapna. How dared she bring in outsiders, the police, to settle the neighbourhood dispute? She is persistently intimidated, abused and harassed. When Shapna refuses to be cowered and continues to protest, her husband, who works as a vendor in a shop run by one of the leading mastans, is summarily sacked from his job to teach Shapna a lesson.

 

The STD clinic run by DMSC as part of their HIV prevention programme in area is closed down.

 

So what is new? Sex workers are after all routinely subjected to violence and human rights abuse all around India and rarely do the administration intervene in their favour. But this incident has a wider significance. For the last ten years, sex workers of Kolkata have been organising themselves to protect their rights and end their exploitation, and had also been in the forefront of an extremely effective HIV prevention programme across West Bengal under the leadership of DMSC. This was no isolated incident against individual sex workers. This was a premeditated act to undermine this

movement, and strike at the heart of its leadership. As marginalised and exploited people come together and attempt to take control of their lives, those whose interests are vested in their subordination have to hit back.

 

On 06 October, two days after the DMSC clinic was reopened in response to local demand, Shapna Gayen’s house was encircled by the same mastans who felt that she and DMSC were a serious threat to their control over the locality. Anticipating violence Shapna summoned police help. While four policemen from the local police station were escorting her out of the area at her insistence, Shapna was dragged away by the mastans and publicly beaten up. While she was held back by her hair by some, the others took their turn to kick and punch her. She is now in hospital. Some of her comrades in DMSC who rushed to the area on hearing about the incident were also beaten up. While Shapna was being beaten the policemen simply looked on. Rekha has been told by the mastans that she will be taken care of once Shapna has been sorted out and put to rest. And the police have refused to accept a first incident report this time. And of course the criminals are running free. No, one person has been arrested and produced in court – though not one of the criminals,but Shapna’s husband, Dilip, who had tried to protecther.

 

Friends, the constitution of our state guarantees equal right and security to all its citizens, irrespective of the class, gender or occupation. The state takes special responsibility towards guaranteeing and promoting the rights of those who have been historically exploited and marginalised. Our public administration is charged to uphold the constitution and law of the land without fear or favour. So why is the police so reluctant to intervene? Why do the Tollygunj mastans, who are known criminals with police records so sure of their immunity from law that they persist in persecuting Shapna? Is it because she is a woman, an under-class, and a sex worker? Or has it more to do with the fact that she the President of DMSC – the largest ever sexworkers’ organisation, which is challenging the verybasis of persisting inequalities and violence on the basis of class, gender and sexuality?

 

We appeal to you to act as individuals or on behalf of your organisation now and write to the Chief Minister of West Bengal, the state Home Ministry, the Human Rights Commission and the National Commission for Women, demanding justice. If we do not protest and act now, once again we will be party to the increasing on the democratic basis of our country.

 

Yours in solidarity,

 

Angura Begum

Secretary, DMSC

Back to top

EUROPAP: Promoting the health and wellbeing of sex workers in Europe

Sexually transmitted infections (STI) are an occupational risk for people who sell sex, but most are very keen to keep themselves and their partners safe. Many people believe that sex workers have a high risk of and play an important role in transmission of STIs. Research in Europe over the past two decades has been important in countering this belief (1-3). Studies consistently show a high rate of condom use in commercial sex, and relatively low risks of HIV and other STI for women sex workers (2,3). A survey of 945 women sex workers in nine European cities in 1990-1 found an overall HIV-1 prevalence of 5.3%, associated with sharing injecting equipment, coming from a high prevalence area, and use of incompatible lubricants during sex. Women who did not inject drugs had a prevalence of 1.5% (1). Two cohort studies in Europe have shown a relatively low incidence of HIV infection (0.2 and 0.9 cases per 100 person years respectively in the United Kingdom and Spain) (2,4). Higher risks have been found in more stigmatised sex workers, including men who sell sex, transgenders, and injecting drug users (5,6).

In 1993 EUROPAP ( http://www.europap.net/ ), the European Network for HIV/STD Prevention in Prostitution, was created to promote the health and wellbeing of sex workers in Europe. This network facilitates the sharing of experience and good practice, assesses the health impacts of different policies on prostitution, and produces training materials. EUROPAP is funded in part by the European Commission, and has representatives in 18 European countries with links to over 400 projects. Earlier this year a successful conference with 180 participants from 39 countries was held (7). EUROPAP works closely with sex worker organisations, as they have a key role to play in advocacy and promoting health through challenging abuse and exploitation.

Over the past decade major social changes have had an impact on prostitution, and EUROPAP has documented these changes and made recommendations to maintain the health of sex workers. For example, increasing mobility has transformed sex work in many European cities. A recent survey has shown that the proportion of migrant workers has increased from 24% in 1990-1 to 56% in 2001 (8). Many migrant workers spend relatively short times in each city, creating challenges for preventive healthcare and management. Together with the TAMPEP (Transnational AIDS/STD Prevention among Migrant Prostitutes in Europe Project) network, EUROPAP has produced Hustling for Health , a manual with advice on best practice in health promotion and healthcare delivery (9). This manual is now available in ten languages, including Russian. Outreach was found to be useful both for reaching sex workers with health promotion messages, and in some situations for directly delivering services such as hepatitis B vaccination (10).

Many European governments have reformed their policies on prostitution in recent years, creating additional challenges. Changes range from legalisation of sex work businesses in the Netherlands to the criminalisation of the buying of sexual services in Sweden. Counter-intuitively, both these reforms appear to have created new obstacles to health promotion and healthcare delivery to the most vulnerable sex workers by making them more hidden. Other governments are looking at reintroducing the registration and mandatory screening of sex workers. This approach is strongly opposed by EUROPAP. Evidence from Greece and Austria, where registration still exists, for example, shows that only a minority of sex workers are in the registered sector, and those who are outside it have little or no access to care, thereby increasing their risks of health problems. Those who are registered are subjected to treatments considered by EUROPAP to be an abuse of human rights, namely having no right to consent to examination and treatments.

A EUROPAP training video for sex workers on tips for safer working is available to healthcare professionals working in this area. A report and video/DVD of the recent EUROPAP conference, Hustling for Health, and a statement on policy are also available. By the end of the current programme (August 2003) EUROPAP will have evidence based guidelines on healthcare and health promotion, a policy resource pack, a searchable database on the internet, and an updated report on health of sex workers from ten countries. Links with European Union applicant countries are being developed, in order to continue the sharing of expertise and good practice. All materials are available from the coordinating centre ( europap@ic.ac.uk ).

References :

1. Alary M. HIV infection in European female sex workers: epidemiological link with use of petroleum-based lubricants. European Working Group on HIV Infection in Female Prostitutes. AIDS 1993; 7 : 401-8.

2. Ward H, Day S, Weber J. Risky business: health and safety in the sex industry over a 9 year period. Sex Transm Infect 1999; 75 : 340-3.

3. Mak R, Plum J, Van Renterghem L. Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection, sexually transmitted diseases and HIV-antibody testing practices in Belgian prostitutes. Genitourin Med 1990; 66:337-41.

4. Vioque J, Hernandez-Aguado I, Fernandez Garcia E, Garcia de la Hera M, Alvarez-Dardet C. Prospective cohort study of female sex workers and the risk of HIV infection in Alicante, Spain (1986-96). Sex Transm Infect 1998; 74 : 284-8.

5.Spizzichino L, Zaccarelli M, Rezza G, Ippolito G, Antinori A, Gattari P. HIV infection among foreign transsexual sex workers in Rome: prevalence, behavior patterns, and seroconversion rates. Sex Transm Dis 2001; 28 : 405-11.

6.Belza MJ, Llacer A, Mora R, Morales M, Castilla J, de la Fuente L. Sociodemographic characteristics and HIV risk behaviour patterns of male sex workers in Madrid, Spain. AIDS Care 2001; 13 : 677-82.

7. EUROPAP. Sex work and health in a changing Europe, 18 – 20 January 2002, Milton Keynes, UK. Organisers’ report ( http://www.europap.net/conference%20reports/organisersreport.html ).

8. Ward H. European perspectives on sex work, migration and health (SS6). Int J STD and AIDS 2002; 13 (supp 1): 5-6.

9. European Network for HIV/STD Prevention in Prostitution. Hustling for Health: developing services for sex workers in Europe. Imperial College London, England; 1999. [available in 10 languages]

10. Mak R, Ven D, Traen A, Claeyssens M, Van Renterghem L, Leroux-Roels G, et al. Hepatitis B vaccination for sex workers: do outreach programmes perform better? Sex Transm Infect. In press 2002.

Reported by Helen Ward ( h.ward@ic.ac.uk ), EUROPAP Coordinator, Clinical Senior Lecturer, Department of Epidemiology and Public Health, Imperial College London, England, and Rudolf Mak ( rudolf.mak@rug.ac.be ), EUROPAP Steering Committee, Staff member, Department of Public Health, Gent University, Belgium.

Back to top

Queen’s AIDS project gets $3 million from U.K.

By Jennifer Pritchett Thursday, October 31, 2002

In an unprecedented move, the British government has donated $3 million to a Queen’s University AIDS research group.

Britain’s Department for International Development is giving the money to the Queen’s Southern African Research Centre’s flagship program, the Southern African Migration Project, over a period of three years.

Researchers are trying to determine why 14 of the top 20 AIDS-stricken countries in the world are in southern Africa. In fact, 70 per cent of the 36 million people infected worldwide with HIV live in sub-Saharan Africa. And the eight countries with the highest rates of HIV infection are in southern Africa. Botswana is first with 43 per cent infected with AIDS, followed by South Africa with an infection rate of 32.5 per cent.

Project director Jonathan Crush said yesterday the donation is generous and most unexpected. “They approached us – it was unsolicited,” he said.

The program, which looks at how AIDS is spreading faster among people who move around a lot, is gaining an international reputation for doing good work in South Africa, said Crush.

“That means that other funders have become interested,” he said. “People out there are seeing the impact of our work.”

And that work – increasing what people know about people in South Africa – can help universities, research institutes and government departments in Botswana, Lesotho, Mozambique, Namibia, South Africa, Swaziland and Zimbabwe devise a solution to the problem.

“It’s to help devise interventions that are sensitive to people’s mobility,” he said.

A recently published paper, co-authored by Crush, points to the importance of the migration issue in explaining the HIV/AIDS epidemic and finding ways to slow its spread.

“Unless the issues of migration and disease are understood and dealt with effectively, it is unlikely that the greater struggle to control and manage AIDS can be won,” he said.

In fact, Crush, who lived in South Africa for three years when the program was just starting in 1996, is returning there next week to meet with governments to discuss AIDS.

Crush is thrilled with the British donation. He said it will double the program’s annual operating budget, which currently receives $1 million from the Canadian International Development Agency.

“It’s a tremendous endorsement and a significant injection of funding,” he said.

Crush said the money will be used to expand the scope of the project and to develop new partnerships with university groups in Malawi, Zambia and Tanzania.

Current partners include the International Organization for Migration in Geneva and the

Ottawa-led International Metropolis Project.

Back to top                        

Gay Sheep May Help Explain Biology of Homosexuals

Reuters (04.11.02)

 

Gay sheep that mate only with other rams have different brain structures from "straight" sheep, a finding that may shed light on human sexuality, US researchers said on Monday.

The differences are similar to those seen in some homosexual humans, but probably only go a small way to explaining the causes of different sexual preferences, the team at Oregon Health & Science University said.

"We are not trying to explain human sexuality by this study," Charles Roselli, a professor of physiology and pharmacology who led the study, said in a telephone interview. "Whether this is a big component of what contributes in humans, that's still debatable."

Working with a team at the US Department of Agriculture's Sheep Experiment Station in Dubois, Idaho, Roselli's team studied 27 sheep--10 ewes, nine rams that mated only with other rams and eight rams that mated only with females.

The "gay" sheep are strongly homosexual, Roselli said.

"They don't pair-bond," he said. "But they are exclusive. They don't court or mate with females. They only court and mate with males."

First the scientists watched the sheep to be sure of their behavior--something that cannot be done with humans. Then they took apart their brains.

"There had been reports in humans that a certain area of the hypothalamus, the preoptic area ... was usually larger in males than females," Roselli said. This area was also found to be larger in heterosexual humans than in homosexual men.

But the researchers had used the brains of men who had died of AIDS in their study, which meant the disease or drugs used to treat it could have had an effect on the brain.

"With an animal model you can be more selective and do more controlled studies," Roselli said.

The sheep had similar differences in their brains, the researchers told a meeting in Orlando, Florida, of the Society for Neuroscience.

"In a sense we confirmed what's been found in humans," Roselli said.

The brain cells in this area also made greater amounts of an enzyme called aromatase in the heterosexual rams. Aromatase is involved in the action of testosterone, the so-called male hormone.

This does not mean the gay rams had less testosterone in their brains, Roselli stressed. "It is not necessarily the activational effect of the hormone," he said. Other types of neurons are probably active--they just have not been identified yet.

No differences in testosterone relating to sexuality have been found either in the sheep or in humans, he said.

"It's not that gay men have lower levels of testosterone," he said. "And it's not the case with these sheep."

Roselli believes that exposure to hormones while still in the mother's womb may affect the brain and cause differences in sexual preference, and more experiments will aim to show whether this is true.

Back to top 

AIDS Deepens in Zimbabwe

AIDS is reducing Zimbabwe’s agricultural labour force by about 10% a year, the United Nations estimated. It forecasts that the disease will shrink the Zimbabwean agricultural workforce by 22.7% in 2020.

Back to top

Scotland Breaks Ranks Over Payouts for Hepatitis C Patients

Haemophiliacs in England and Wales infected with the liver-damaging hepatitis C virus through tainted blood transfusions had no case for NHS compensation, the government has said, after it appeared that those in Scotland would receive payouts. The Scottish executive’s health minister, Malcolm Chisholm, welcomed a report recommending that a fund be set up immediately for those with hepatitis C who could prove they had been given infected blood or blood products by the health service.

 

Back to top

 

home home
contact wmplondon contact us 
home visiting the WMP
symptoms and self-testing symptoms
legal issues law
symptoms and self-testing working safety
symptoms and self-testing HIV and AIDS
symptoms and self-testing condoms
news and information news
news and information acknowledgements 
links links